Today I was confronted by an exhibition of blind, unwavering faith that I found quite alarming. My brother in law told my son (James - he has a keen interest in dinosaurs) that according to the Bible, not only did man once co-exist with dinosaurs, but that some dinosaurs were present on Noahs' Ark.
My son, who is quite well read on the scientific points of evolution, quickly pointed out how absurd this was based on the geological records' clear indication that the last dinosaurs died 65 million years ago, whereas modern humans only appeared 10 thousand or so years ago.
My own reading (in particular Stephen Hawkings' "Brief History of Time") has cast serious doubts on my own faith. The uncertainty principle of quatum mechanics would, from a mathematical viewpoint, appear to be a veritable disproval of the existance of a God who cared to take any active role in the development of creation. Quantum mechnics implies that if there is a God, He created the Universe and left it to run under a strict set of laws set at the moment of creation. The "big" point being that if this is the case, He chose to have no further dealings with the development of the Universe and "free will" (for instance, the ability to choose between following a religion, or not following one) does not even exist. The particles that make up our bodies, the life around us, our planet, everything are simply following paths set at the moment of creation (the Big Bang).
So, as a father, what do I tell my son? To believe, blindly, in the Bible, or to believe what he can see (and what science can "prove" is real).
The belief in a God precludes the need for proof. Proof of a God would deny the existance of such a being by removing the need for belief.
If there is a "God" and a "Heaven", what is the real purpose of this existance? Simply to make God know we believe and then to get the ultimate prize of immortality? Sounds like a cheap way to get what we all really crave - and if life has taught me anything, nothing cheap is really worthwhile. Why would God treat humans any differently from all the other myriad ilfeforms on this sphere (including the Moselms, Jews, Hindus you name it).
I'm sorry, but this is the worst kind of false hope imaginable. Am I really to believe that all the people who lived prior to Christs birth are condemned to eternal damnation, or just cold death, whereas thos born after Him, and follow his faith can be "saved" and rewarded withh eternal life? It's gotta be bollocks. I'm sticking with Jediism for now.
My son, who is quite well read on the scientific points of evolution, quickly pointed out how absurd this was based on the geological records' clear indication that the last dinosaurs died 65 million years ago, whereas modern humans only appeared 10 thousand or so years ago.
My own reading (in particular Stephen Hawkings' "Brief History of Time") has cast serious doubts on my own faith. The uncertainty principle of quatum mechanics would, from a mathematical viewpoint, appear to be a veritable disproval of the existance of a God who cared to take any active role in the development of creation. Quantum mechnics implies that if there is a God, He created the Universe and left it to run under a strict set of laws set at the moment of creation. The "big" point being that if this is the case, He chose to have no further dealings with the development of the Universe and "free will" (for instance, the ability to choose between following a religion, or not following one) does not even exist. The particles that make up our bodies, the life around us, our planet, everything are simply following paths set at the moment of creation (the Big Bang).
So, as a father, what do I tell my son? To believe, blindly, in the Bible, or to believe what he can see (and what science can "prove" is real).
The belief in a God precludes the need for proof. Proof of a God would deny the existance of such a being by removing the need for belief.
If there is a "God" and a "Heaven", what is the real purpose of this existance? Simply to make God know we believe and then to get the ultimate prize of immortality? Sounds like a cheap way to get what we all really crave - and if life has taught me anything, nothing cheap is really worthwhile. Why would God treat humans any differently from all the other myriad ilfeforms on this sphere (including the Moselms, Jews, Hindus you name it).
I'm sorry, but this is the worst kind of false hope imaginable. Am I really to believe that all the people who lived prior to Christs birth are condemned to eternal damnation, or just cold death, whereas thos born after Him, and follow his faith can be "saved" and rewarded withh eternal life? It's gotta be bollocks. I'm sticking with Jediism for now.
Labels: is there really a god?
TomcatUK - Andy Fletcher's Blog
4 Comments:
Andy Fletcher,
Maybe you would enjoy reading Andy Fletcher's book "Life, The Universe and Everything: Investigating God and the New Physics"
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Life-Universe-Everything-Investigating-Physics/dp/1411673697/ref=sr_1_1/203-3358168-4396762?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1180342324&sr=1-1
Paul
Hi Paul, now that is a little disconcerting - I've heard of Andy Fletcher of Depeche mode, and I believe there's another notable character who hosts chat shows in the USA and shares my name. Now I see there's an author too - looks like I'm in auspicious company! I think I'll have to get a copy on principle - the fact it ties in with my blog post so tightly is incredible!
Andy Fletcher,
OK, now this is strange. I'm the Andy Fletcher who wrote the book Paul referred you to. It's not often that both ends of an email have your, or my, or whatever, name on them.
Anyway, found you while googling myself (don't go there), and I have to know: did you buy the book? and, what do you think? BTW, the book comes from presentations I do in, among other places, British schools. Will be back in Nov -- watch the website for dates/locations. You should come. Two of us in the same room -- worth a visit, just for that.
Cheers,
(you know)
Hi Andy - boy, this is a strange set of circumstances and no mistake! I'm not altogether sure how Paul found my blog in the first place (unless he was also Googling Andy Fletcher of course - as far as I know it's the only phrase this blog makes page 1 of Google for).
I've had a bit of trouble getting hold of a copy - I usually buy things like books on the high street as I don't like having to wait for them to turn up. Finally gave up and have ordered it through Amazon as Paul originally suggested. I'll pop a pic of me with the book when I have it onto the blog for posterity. Very much looking forward to reading it after what I saw on tokseminars. Is that your site? Very nicely done, although for some reason not in Googles' index - maybe the backlink from here will help.
When I've read it, I'll put up a new post about it.
Would be interesting to see you when you're next in the UK - I could even get my copy autographed which would be cool! If you ever want to get in touch directly, the contact form on this site sends e-mail directly to me - or you can mail direct at andy@tomcatuk.net.
Hope you get around to checking back as I don't seem to have found a way to contact you directly.
All the best
you know who!
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home